Welcome to New Haven Pizza
At New Haven Pizza, we celebrate the art of pizza-making, rooted in tradition yet bursting with innovation. Located in West Chester, PA, our pizzeria is a welcoming haven for everyone, whether you're dining with family, friends, or enjoying a cozy evening outdoors. We pride ourselves on offering a diverse menu with abundant vegetarian options, appealing to all palates. Our casual atmosphere is perfect for lunch or dinner, while our attentive staff ensures a delightful experience. From delicious pizzas to wholesome catering options, New Haven Pizza is more than just a meal—it's a community gathering place where flavors and friendships bloom.
- 18 N Church St West Chester, PA 19382 United States Hotline: (610) 436-5814
Welcome to New Haven Pizza, where the art of pizza-making meets a cozy dining experience in the heart of West Chester, PA. Located at 18 N Church St, this inviting eatery captures the essence of classic Italian flavors while offering a modern twist that caters to all palates.
At New Haven Pizza, every dish tells a story. The menu boasts an array of options, ensuring that both meat lovers and vegetarians find something to love. From traditional cheese and pepperoni pies to loaded vegetarian options, each pizza is crafted using fresh ingredients and perfected with a hint of love. You can even savor your favorite slice on their outdoor patio, making it a fantastic spot for family dinners or casual gatherings.
- Delivery & Takeout: Enjoy hassle-free dining at home with their reliable delivery service or choose takeout when you’re on the go.
- Reservations: Whether it's a special occasion or a casual night out, make your visit effortless by reserving a table ahead of time.
- Casual Atmosphere: Perfect for groups, families, and kids, the vibrant yet relaxed environment ensures everyone feels welcome.
- Beer & Wine Only: Complement your meal with a selection of fine wines or local beers from their thoughtfully curated beverage menu.
- Additional Perks: Free Wi-Fi, TV entertainment, and dog-friendly seating make it a versatile dining experience.
One of the standout features of New Haven Pizza is its dedication to quality and community. They not only provide an impressive array of toppings but also emphasize serving their customers with a smile. The staff's warmth paired with the moderate, lively ambiance contributes to an enjoyable dining experience, whether you’re here for lunch, dinner, or catering your next big event.
If you’re in the West Chester area, don’t miss your chance to explore New Haven Pizza. Whether dining in or taking out, this restaurant promises satisfaction with every bite. For inquiries or to place an order, give them a call at (610) 436-5814.
Indulge in deliciousness today at New Haven Pizza—where every slice is a masterpiece!

The best!! Worth the walk to walk in and smell and feel the love going in here. Its my new only pizza place. Love

Ive been coming here for as long as I can remember. Im from the area, but now live out of state, and this is a mustvisit every time I come back home to see family. Having grown up in the northeast, living in NYC for a time, and eating ...

The pizza and wings are excellent! Even the blue cheese and celery are good! Strongly recommend!

The menu board said the cheesesteaks are made with 7 ounces of sirloin. That sounded small and since we were in West Chester I went with the small plate mentality and got the special steak. I am glad I did. I knew I was in for a treat when ...

Consistenly the best and freshest food! I am super picky with salads and they nail it every single time! Lettuce is never brown or wilted. Their tuna is EXCELLENT! Their chicken fingers are also amazing, too! Highly highly recc! Thank you, New Haven for consistently fresh AND delicious food which is a rare thing these days!!!!!

The absolute best. The food, plentiful and affordable, always made with very fresh ingredients. You have to consider this a Greek style pizza type restaurant. These haters just dont know what kind of place they are dealing with. Get the ...

This is the way all little restaurants should aspire to. Old school and modern at the same time. Great food and not corporate cookie cutter fare. Lots of daily specials and everything is reasonably priced. Very friendly staff. A must visit for a cozy lunch or dinner. Eat in or take out. A West Chester institution.

Very friendly staff. Quick service. Clean toilets. Parking is very difficult because of construction in the area. The food was very good. I had the pizza. They have everything that you can want for a small family style restaurant. I would definitely recommend.